Gaming

How to Open a Marketplace Dispute: Evidence Checklist

Updated 2026-10-01 · 2 min read

Affiliate disclosure: some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

When a digital order goes wrong, what you do in the first hour often decides the outcome. This checklist covers the steps and the evidence that make a dispute easier to resolve.

Compare live offers Affiliate link. Read the risks below first.

Topic: When orders fail
First step: Do not confirm
Key proof: Screenshots, recording
Tip: Act quickly

Stop and do not confirm

Do not mark the order complete or release payment while there is a problem. Confirming usually closes the door on a dispute.

Do not pay anything extra, even if the seller says it will fix the problem. Extra payments off-platform are a common scam.

Gather your evidence

Take screenshots of the offer, the order page and the chat. Save any screen recording of the trade or redemption attempt.

Note the time of each step, including when the seller said they would deliver. For codes, capture the exact error message.

Contact the seller, then escalate

Write a short, polite message in the order chat stating what is wrong and what you expect. Keep every message on the platform.

If the seller does not fix it within a reasonable time, open a dispute using the platform's own tool and attach your evidence. Stay factual and avoid insults.

Risks to understand

Dispute windows are limited. Act quickly and check the platform's deadlines.
Evidence from outside the platform may not be accepted. Keep chat on the order page.
Outcomes depend on the evidence and the marketplace's rules. There is no guaranteed result.

Ready to compare? Prices and availability change often, so see what is listed right now, then run through the checklist above before you pay.

See today's offers

FAQ

How soon should I open a dispute?

As soon as it is clear the order will not be fixed. Windows are limited and vary by marketplace.

What is the best evidence?

Clear screenshots of the offer, the chat and the problem, plus a screen recording of the trade or redemption.

Can I dispute after confirming an order?

Often not. This is why you should confirm only after checking delivery.

More guides

Safe Digital Goods is an independent site. It is not owned by, affiliated with or endorsed by G2G. G2G and all game, software and brand names are trademarks of their respective owners.